The Year in Review & The Year Ahead


The Year In Review: 2013 brought us some great insight into the field of Reasonable Compensation by way of the McAlary case.

Compensation Agreements – McAlary had a Compensation Agreement, but the courts didn’t buy it: “We are not persuaded that the remuneration agreement represents a sound measure of the value of the services that Mr. McAlary provided to petitioner during 2006. We cast a sceptical eye on the agreement inasmuch as Mr. McAlary sat on both sides of the table when the agreement was executed, occupying the positions of both employer and employee. The agreement clearly was not the product of an arms-length negotiation.”

Take Away – Even though compensation agreements are 1 of 9 factors the courts will consider when determining Reasonable Compensation they need to be reasonable, represent real value, and be negotiated between disinterested parties.

 – This is the magic number for multiplying an hourly wage to get an annual salary.  The Bureau of Labor Statistics defines “year-round, full-time” employment as 2,080 hours per year (40 hours per week).  Both the IRS expert and the courts used this number to determine McAlary’s Reasonable Compensation figure from an hourly wage figure, even though McAlary regularly worked 12 hours days and six to seven days a week.

Take Away
 – This is one of the few pieces of guidance the courts and the IRS have given us that actually makes things clearer and simpler.  (RCReports has always used 2,080 as full-time year-round employment in its algorithms.)

The Year Ahead: 2014 looks like a year that we will see another increase in S Corp audits.

How Compensatory Intent Affects Compensation Deductions

For a corporation to deduct a payment made to a shareholder/employee as compensation, compensatory intent must exist.  Originally published in on December 7, 2023. Copyright: AICPA.  It is well known…
Business Valuations February 22, 2024

Paying for Personal Guaranties of Company Debts

Originally published in The Tax Adviser, September 2022. Copyright: AICPA It is common for business owners to personally guarantee company debts. This is a valuable service since many private companies…
Business Valuations February 21, 2024

How S Corp Shareholder Health Insurance Works

Best Practices February 15, 2024

Start exploring RCReports today.

        Submit a Ticket

          Scroll to Top